The House of Commons has passed
draft legislation that will make the United Kingdom (UK) the first
country to permit "three parent" babies. MPs voted 382 to 128 in support
of The Human Fertilisation and Embryology (Mitochondrial Donation) Regulations 2015 from the Department of Health that will permit mitochondrial DNA transfer. The treatment combines the genetic material from the eggs of two women with the sperm of a man to produce an IVF embryo that has DNA from three individuals.
The Regulations would permit two techniques: Maternal Spindle Transfer,
which modifies the mother's egg pre-fertilization and Pro Nuclear
Transfer, which modifies an existing embryo in attempts to prevent the
transfer of mitochondrial disease from mother to child.
MPs approved the
Regulations despite serious safety, ethical and legal concerns with the
untested practice. Not only will mitochondrial donation open the door to
the eugenics of "designer children" with the favoring of certain traits
over others, it shows no dignity for the preborn child, who is created
and destroyed at will. The practice itself is untested. Fiona Bruce MP asked, "Where
will it lead? The answer has to be that we stop here. The answer has to
be that we say this is a red line in our country, as in every other
country in the world, that we will not cross."
Robert Flello MP also voiced concern, "The
Human Fertilisation and Embryology authority (HFEA) themselves
acknowledge that in approving this there is a significant chance of
mutant DNA being created."
CARE for Europe expressed opposition and deep concern stating, "...it
is interrupting and recreating complex biological relationships at the
very base of our humanity. It has been forbidden largely because of the
permanent alteration of the germline which would result - thereby
performing eugenics, a fundamental change for the children and
grandchildren, and beyond."
The proposed
Regulations go against international law. 46 Members of the European
Parliament sent an open letter to UK health secretary Jeremy Hunt
opposing the proposal, warning that it would violate an EU ban on the
use of germline manipulation in clinical trials, and expressing deep
concern for the impact of the techniques. Dr Miroslav Mikolasik, Chair
of the European Parliament Bioethical Working Group, warned in the
letter, "We strongly believe this medical technique
which is being developed to help small number of women affected by rare
genetic disease would negatively affect all of humanity by establishing
precedent for cloning and thus alteration of human species and
destruction of our shared human heritage."
The proposal awaits consideration in the House of Lords on February 23rd.
Meanwhile, meetings are underway in the United States by a committee
tasked to address the question of mitochondrial DNA transfer and issue a
consensus study on the ethical and social policy issues surrounding the
technique. The first meeting was held on January 27th, with a second
scheduled for March with a 2-day public workshop and a closed committee session. A
public comment session is planned for the third committee meeting in
May 2015 to be followed by two closed committee meetings during which
the committee will draft and finalize the report.